A Legally Defensible Firearms Program

A Legally Defensible Firearms Program

By Lt. Matt Borders and Lt. John Weinstein
Northern Virginia Community College Police Department
4001 Wakefield Chapel Road (Ste. 117)
Annandale, VA 22003
703-764-5000

Disclaimer: The views expressed herein represent the personal views of the authors and should not be construed as representing the official view of the Northern Virginia Community College or any of its components.

Introduction

The operation and maintenance of a law enforcement firearms program is an extraordinarily complex operation[1]. Questions of equipment, training, back-up weapons, inspection programs, documentation, and safety are only a few of the crucial issues faced by police chiefs and sheriffs. Weapons proficiency is an essential component of officer safety, but proficiency by itself is not enough. Officers[2] must also become proficient in making life-or-death, shoot-don’t shoot decisions, both to protect themselves and the citizens they serve.

Intense public scrutiny of use of force decisions pales to insignificance in comparison to that exercised in incidents involving deadly force. The ability of an officer to take a life in the line of duty is the most awesome example of a society’s public trust in law enforcement and, therefore, is rightly accorded intense scrutiny and understandably surrounded by emotion.

In such an environment, it is hardly surprising that individual officers, law enforcement agencies, and the communities and institutions they serve find themselves as defendants in criminal and civil legal proceedings. Whether charged with the violation of an individual’s civil rights under federal statutes or civil charges of wrongful death, gross negligence, vicarious liability, etc., a legally defensible firearms program is necessary (though not sufficient) to protect officers and departments from legal assault and maintain public trust in law enforcement.

Elements of a Legally Defensible Firearms Program

Eight safeguards can support a department’s claim of legal defensibility. Readers should review the court cases below for a full understanding of the rationales behind their decisions. Also, these decisions, having been made 28-42 years ago, are well-established and therefore legitimate bases upon which to judge a firearms program.

1. Don’t just qualify. Train!

There is a big difference between punching holes in a target and shooting in a combat situation. Successful qualification means an officer has some minimum level of proficiency in the components of firing a weapon (grip, sight alignment, trigger control, follow-through, etc.). Qualification does not say much about why an officer decided to use his or her weapon or how he employed it. Firearms instructors who simply proctor qualifications and score targets are helping their officers meet minimum state standards; they are not teaching their officers how to survive because gun-fighting bears little resemblance to qualifying. Further, target scorers are doing nothing to help their officers or departments survive a legal challenge. City of Canton v. Harris requires training; simple qualifications do not reduce a department’s liability. Prudent department leaders should expect firearms (and other) training records to be subpoenaed. A lesson plan and documented training for each officer will be paramount in protecting an officer, trainers, and the entire department from criminal and/or civil suits.

2. Low-Light Training, Shooting in Residential Areas, and Engaging Moving Targets.

The range is not the street. Shooting at the range is artificial because it often avoids the very characteristics found in actual combat: screaming; confusion; citizens running for cover, possibly within an officer’s field of fire; inordinate stress; the need to clear malfunctions while under fire; fear; etc.[3] Consider, for instance, an officer required to conduct a building search at midday. There is a significant chance the officer’s life may rely on his or her ability to shoot with a flashlight, employ it to discern adversaries from innocents, and to employ it in a way that doesn’t reduce officer safety. Further, how many officers train on engaging a legitimate moving target, one that is moving laterally and not just turning in place? In Popow v. City of Margate (1979), the court found a program “grossly inadequate” because the officers received no training on night shooting, shooting in residential areas, and night shooting. The court further found the officers had not been exposed to films or simulators designed to explain how the laws are applied[4].

3. Shoot/Don’t Shoot Training.

The vast majority of officers never fire their weapon (apart from training) in the line of duty. However, many officers draw their weapons but never shoot. This fact suggests officers must make frequent “shoot/don’t shoot” decisions. In the case of a “don’t shoot” decision, are the officers being trained to articulate what the suspect must do in a clear and understandable way? What if an officer has occasion to holster his or her weapon but then must go “hands on” to cuff a suspect. In other words, an officer doesn’t fire a weapon each time it’s drawn, so training must also anticipate and train officers for both lethal and non-lethal outcomes, when to know when the latter is required, and how to execute that decision. Too often, firearms training is divorced from defensive/control tactics training. The use of AirSoft, blue guns, and other non-lethal weapons, preferably with role players, is an essential part of a well-balanced firearms program. Zuchel v. Denver and a subsequent appeal affirmed the need to conduct live fire training with shoot/don’t shoot drills. Training films and firearms simulators, while useful, do not suffice by themselves.

4. Review the Department’s Use of Force Policy.

Officers must remain current with your department’s use of force policy. As with every general order, each officer should review its content and then formally acknowledge by signature his or her understanding. Like firearms proficiency itself, which is perishable in the absence of regular training, familiarity with firearms and use of force general orders should be maintained on a regular basis. The best way to do this is to review key guidance and responsibilities each time the officers go to the range or engage in other related training, such as defensive tactics. A one- or two-page summary of each policy is helpful. At each training session, officers should sign and date one after reviewing it and retain the other. The signed copy should be placed in their training folder. Other topics meriting review include important case law, such as Graham v. Connor, Payne v. Pauley, Tennessee v. Garner, and Montoute v. Carr. It is also a good idea to also review policies covering different less-lethal weapons officers may carry. This review should include what level of force they are considered in the department’s use of force policy, the proper use of these assets, and other reporting and medical responsibilities.

5. Back-up and Off-duty Weapons.

Many officers carry back-up and off-duty weapons. Some departments prohibit the former while others allow them. Is there a program to inspect off-duty weapons, are they carried in a location that ensures their security? Are double or triple retention holsters required? Are there caliber limitations? Are single-action weapons allowed? Must the weapons have a manual safety? All these considerations may be challenged if a back-up weapon is used in an armed on-duty encounter. Regarding off-duty weapons, if used in conjunction with an officer’s police authority, certain dangers and liabilities may attach themselves. A weapon used off-duty but under police authority is subject to many if not all of the considerations discussed above. Furthermore, how will the officer, presumably out of uniform, prevent being mistaken for an assailant by responding uniform officers? What training has been provided on how to draw a concealed weapon? How will the officer communicate with local dispatch without a radio? What documentation is required and how soon? What are state and federal rules regarding off-duty carry? For instance, some states only permit their officers to carry hollow-point ammunition, possibly subjecting an out-of-state officer who uses approved duty ammunition from his or her department to arrest. These questions have answers but the topic needs to be addressed as part of a comprehensive firearms program. Indeed, Young v. City of Providence identifies off-duty weapons requirements and responsibilities.

6. Weapons Inspections.

Weapons must be maintained in clean and operating order at all times. A weapon that fails to fire or, perhaps due to non-functioning night sights for instance, can risk an officer’s life or result in shooting an innocent person. Weapons carried daily by officers are subject to the accumulation of lint, moisture, grime (especially if the weapon is not cleaned regularly), and the failure of internal parts. Holsters can fail too. It is imperative that all weapons (both handguns and long guns) and associated equipment be inspected annually by a certified departmental armorer. Additionally, firearms instructors should inspect weapons, holsters and associated equipment at each range training or qualification session. Finally, supervisors should perform visual inspections (after weapons are made safe) as part of regular uniform and equipment inspections. All inspection results should be documented.

7. Document, Document, Document!

In Young v. City of Providence, the court mandated the need for documentation. In this case, shoot/don’t shoot training had been properly documented and as a result a summary judgement was granted to the city of Providence. Documentation should include, at a minimum, the following:

  • Firearms training lesson plans, including each course of fire
  • Attendance rosters
  • Signed acknowledgements of firearms safety rules, range rules and other policies such as use of force and firearms
  • Range safety plan (i.e., location of hospital, who transports, etc.)
  • Courses of fire
  • Officers’ performance
  • Instruction given or remedial training for any officer

8. Periodically Evaluate Your Program.

Laws change, societal attitudes change, new court cases are announced, technology evolves, department priorities change and a host of other factors can affect your firearms program. A program that was defensible in 2010 may no longer be so in 2021. A chief or sheriff, unless he or she is a qualified firearms instructor, is in no position to evaluate the department’s firearms program; it is up to you as the firearms instructor. There are many moving parts to a firearms program, with more than 100 variables falling into one of five categories: personnel, procedures, facilities, equipment and communications. A comprehensive assessment should be conducted on a regular basis, say every 5-10 years, to ensure the department’s program is both effective and defensible[5].

A final word

There are few activities in law enforcement as important, dangerous, and final as the use of firearms. As a result, firearms policies, equipment and practices are often suggested to social and judicial scrutiny. Any use of force involving the discharge of a firearm will end up in court. Protecting your department, yourself as a training, and your officers demands a comprehensive and well documented approach to firearms training. The points discussed above serve as a starting point.

Notes

  1. See Weinstein, John, 2014-5, “Considerations When Developing an Officer Firearms Program”, parts 1 and 2. https://www.campussafetymagazine.com/news/5\_considerations\_when\_developing\_an\_officer\_firearms\_program/ ; https://www.campussafetymagazine.com/safety/5\_more\_considerations\_when\_developing\_an\_officer\_firearms\_program/
  2. Throughout this essay, officers is used to signify police officers, deputy sheriffs, and other armed sworn personnel at local, state, tribal and federal levels.
  3. Weinstein, John, 2021, “Are We Failing Our Officers?” The Firearms Instructor, IALEFI (forthcoming).
  4. Officers trained only twice a year at the range. Although the court did not specify a minimum number of training dates per year, Popow suggests that semi-annual training may not be enough to protect a department from accusations of failure to train.
  5. An assessment methodology will be presented by Lt. Weinstein at IALEFI’s 2021 Annual Training Conference. Contact him (jweinstein@nvcc.edu) for information on how to conduct this assessment.

References

Leo and Arlene ZUCHEL v. The CITY AND COUNTY OF DENVER, COLORADO,
Nos. 91-1379, 91-1395 and 91-1400. United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit.
June 23, 1993.
Rehearing Denied Aug. 23, 1993.

POPOW v. CITY OF MARGATE, 476 F. Supp. 1237 (D.N.J. 1979)
US District Court for the District of New Jersey – 476 F. Supp. 1237 (D.N.J. 1979)
August 31, 1979

YOUNG v. CITY OF PROVIDENCE, 301 F. Supp. 2d 163 (D.R.I. 2004)
US District Court for the District of Rhode Island – 301 F. Supp. 2d 163 (D.R.I. 2004)
February 11, 2004

CITY OF CANTON, OHIO v. HARRIS, 489 U.S. 378 (1989)
No. 86-1088. Argued November 8, 1988
Decided February 28, 1989

IALEFI

Born out of a shared concern for advancing the standards and techniques of law enforcement firearms instruction in 1981, IALEFI® has emerged as a prominent non-profit association leading the charge for modernized, high-caliber firearms training. With an elected Board of Directors from our diverse and global membership, we address universal challenges in the firearms instruction domain.
IALEFI Podcast

Zero'd In